Kelvin Gastelum vs. Joe Pyfer - UFC 316: Dvalishvili vs. O'Malley 2 Results & AI Breakdown

Winner: Joe Pyfer by Decision - Unanimous

Fight Info:
Location: Newark, New Jersey, USA
Elevation: 4.00m
Weight Class: Middleweight
Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org…

The content below shows how the model reached its conclusion for the prediction. The higher the value of the number, the more confident the model is in the prediction. The confidence scores do not perfectly correlate with accuracy. Use your judgement to see where the model may have missed the mark.

The predictions below are shown in dark grey if they were correct, incorxrect predictions are shown in red.
Predictions
W = WTAI Model O = Profit Model P = Plain Model EV = Expected Value
Fighter
Confidence
EV
Odds
W
O
P
Kelvin Gastelum
2
3
+290
Joe Pyfer
20
-1.2
-410

Weighted Scoring Report

Weighted Score for WTAI Prediction

Predicted Winner: Joe Pyfer

Weight Class: Middleweight

Final Confidence: 24.0

Confidence Adjustments

Value: +20.0%

Reason: Base confidence between 14 and 21, increased by 20%

Fighter History & Outcomes

Kelvin Gastelum

Weight Change: Staying at usual weight

Fight History:

  • June 22, 2024: Kelvin Gastelum won against Daniel Rodriguez. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 28 - 29. 27 - 30. 27 - 30.
  • December 2, 2023: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Sean Brady. The fight ended in round 3 at 1:43. Method of victory: Submission.
  • April 8, 2023: Kelvin Gastelum won against Chris Curtis. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 28 - 29. 28 - 29. 27 - 30.
  • August 21, 2021: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Jared Cannonier. The fight ended in round 5 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 47 - 48. 47 - 48. 47 - 48.
  • April 17, 2021: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Robert Whittaker. The fight ended in round 5 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 45 - 50. 45 - 50. 45 - 50.
  • February 13, 2021: Kelvin Gastelum won against Ian Heinisch. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 27 - 30. 28 - 29. 28 - 29.
  • July 18, 2020: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Jack Hermansson. The fight ended in round 1 at 1:18. Method of victory: Submission.
  • November 2, 2019: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Darren Till. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a split decision. Additional details: 30 - 27. 28 - 29. 27 - 30.
  • April 13, 2019: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Israel Adesanya. The fight ended in round 5 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 46 - 48. 46 - 48. 46 - 48.
  • May 12, 2018: Kelvin Gastelum won against Jacare Souza. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a split decision. Additional details: 28 - 29. 29 - 28. 28 - 29.
  • November 25, 2017: Kelvin Gastelum won against Michael Bisping. The fight ended in round 1 at 2:30. Method of victory: KO/TKO.
  • July 22, 2017: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Chris Weidman. The fight ended in round 3 at 3:45. Method of victory: Submission.
  • March 11, 2017: Kelvin Gastelum had an inconclusive result against Vitor Belfort. The fight went the distance (5 Rnd (5-5-5-5-5)).
  • December 10, 2016: Kelvin Gastelum won against Tim Kennedy. The fight ended in round 3 at 2:45. Method of victory: KO/TKO.
  • July 9, 2016: Kelvin Gastelum won against Johny Hendricks. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 28 - 29. 27 - 30. 27 - 30.
  • November 21, 2015: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Neil Magny. The fight ended in round 5 at 5:00. It was a split decision. Additional details: 47 - 48. 48 - 47. 47 - 48.
  • June 13, 2015: Kelvin Gastelum won against Nate Marquardt. The fight ended in round 2 at 5:00. Method of victory: KO/TKO.
  • January 31, 2015: Kelvin Gastelum lost against Tyron Woodley. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a split decision. Additional details: 28 - 29. 29 - 28. 27 - 30.
  • November 15, 2014: Kelvin Gastelum won against Jake Ellenberger. The fight ended in round 1 at 4:46. Method of victory: Submission.
  • June 28, 2014: Kelvin Gastelum won against Nicholas Musoke. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 28 - 29. 28 - 29. 28 - 29.
  • March 15, 2014: Kelvin Gastelum won against Rick Story. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a split decision. Additional details: 29 - 28. 28 - 29. 27 - 30.
  • August 28, 2013: Kelvin Gastelum won against Brian Melancon. The fight ended in round 1 at 2:26. Method of victory: Submission.
  • April 13, 2013: Kelvin Gastelum won against Uriah Hall. The fight ended in round 3 at 5:00. It was a split decision. Additional details: 28 - 29. 29 - 28. 28 - 29.
Joe Pyfer

Weight Change: Staying at usual weight

Fight History:

  • June 29, 2024: Joe Pyfer won against Marc-Andre Barriault. The fight ended in round 1 at 1:25. Method of victory: KO/TKO.
  • February 10, 2024: Joe Pyfer lost against Jack Hermansson. The fight ended in round 5 at 5:00. It was a unanimous decision. Additional details: 47 - 48. 47 - 48. 47 - 48.
  • October 7, 2023: Joe Pyfer won against Abdul Razak Alhassan. The fight ended in round 2 at 2:05. Method of victory: Submission.
  • April 8, 2023: Joe Pyfer won against Gerald Meerschaert. The fight ended in round 1 at 3:15. Method of victory: KO/TKO.
  • September 17, 2022: Joe Pyfer won against Alen Amedovski. The fight ended in round 1 at 3:55. Method of victory: KO/TKO.

Fight Analysis

Analysis: Kelvin Gastelum vs Joe Pyfer

WolfTicketsAI Predicts Joe Pyfer to Win

Score: 20
Odds:
Kelvin Gastelum: 290
Joe Pyfer: -410

Kelvin Gastelum's Breakdown

Gastelum brings a wealth of UFC experience to this matchup as a veteran who's faced elite competition throughout his career. His technical approach centers around his southpaw boxing and underrated wrestling background. Gastelum's game is built on his quick hands and ability to close distance explosively.

His first signature technique is his blitzing left straight-right hook combination. Against Daniel Rodriguez in his last fight, Gastelum repeatedly landed this combination by closing distance rapidly and catching Rodriguez off-guard with his speed. This same combination stunned Israel Adesanya in their title fight, showing its effectiveness against even elite strikers.

Gastelum's second key weapon is his body work, particularly his left straight to the body. Against Chris Curtis, he consistently targeted the midsection, slowing Curtis down and creating openings upstairs. This body-head attack pattern makes him dangerous in extended exchanges.

In the clinch, Gastelum employs effective double collar tie control that allows him to deliver damaging knee strikes. Against Curtis, he seamlessly transitioned to this position when Curtis shelled up to defend body strikes, showing excellent phase-shifting abilities.

Gastelum has evolved technically in recent fights, showing improved lateral movement and calf kicks. Against Rodriguez, he consistently circled to his left, creating angles to land southpaw calf kicks while Rodriguez struggled to reorient himself.

Kelvin Gastelum's Technical Vulnerabilities

Gastelum's first major vulnerability is his defensive lapses when pressuring forward. Against Sean Brady, he repeatedly overcommitted to his offensive entries, leaving his head centered and vulnerable to counter strikes. Brady capitalized by timing simple jabs that caught Gastelum off-balance throughout their fight.

His second weakness is his tendency to reset with his chin high after combinations. This was exploited by Robert Whittaker, who consistently caught Gastelum during these reset moments. Even in his recent win against Rodriguez, Gastelum showed this same technical flaw, though Rodriguez failed to capitalize.

When his primary gameplan fails, Gastelum often doubles down on his blitzing entries rather than making tactical adjustments. Against Jack Hermansson, when his initial striking approach was neutralized, Gastelum continued with the same entries, leading to a quick heel hook submission when he overcommitted to a blitz.

Gastelum also struggles with weight management, which has affected his conditioning and power. Against Rodriguez, he missed weight by a significant margin, potentially compromising his optimal fighting weight and performance quality.

Joe Pyfer's Breakdown

Pyfer brings devastating power and finishing ability to this matchup. His recent first-round knockout of Marc-Andre Barriault showcased his pressure-based approach and fight-ending power. Pyfer's game revolves around cutting off the cage and creating situations where his power punches can land with maximum impact.

His first signature technique is his thunderous overhand right. Against Barriault, Pyfer systematically pressured him to the fence, limiting his movement options. When Barriault attempted to circle away, Pyfer timed a perfect overhand right that landed flush, dropping him instantly. This same punch has been the finishing blow in multiple fights.

Pyfer's second key weapon is his up-jab to right straight combination. Against Alen Amedovski, he used this sequence to devastating effect. The up-jab disrupted Amedovski's vision and lifted his guard, creating the perfect lane for the fight-ending right hand that followed.

In grappling exchanges, Pyfer shows excellent top control and submission awareness. Against Abdul Razak Alhassan, he methodically set up and finished an arm triangle choke after securing mount position. This demonstrated his patience and technical precision in submission setups.

Pyfer has shown technical evolution in his pressure fighting, particularly in his ability to cut off the cage more efficiently. Against Barriault, his footwork to maintain pressure while avoiding counterattacks showed significant improvement from earlier performances.

Joe Pyfer's Technical Vulnerabilities

Pyfer's first major vulnerability is his defensive positioning during forward pressure. Against Jack Hermansson, he kept his right hand somewhat low while loading up on power shots, creating counter opportunities. Hermansson exploited this with an effective jab both on the front foot and while retreating.

His second weakness is his limited head movement, particularly when pressuring forward. Against Hermansson, Pyfer relied heavily on his high guard but didn't incorporate sufficient slipping or rolling, making him susceptible to straight punches down the middle. Hermansson repeatedly landed his jab as Pyfer walked forward without adequate defensive movement.

When his primary gameplan fails, Pyfer struggles to make technical adjustments. In the Hermansson fight, when his power punching approach was neutralized by Hermansson's jab and movement, Pyfer briefly switched to southpaw seeking a new angle. However, when Hermansson immediately adjusted his kicking strategy, Pyfer abandoned the stance change rather than developing a new approach.

Pyfer also shows vulnerability to leg kicks, particularly calf kicks. While not fully exploited in recent fights, his stance and defensive reactions leave him somewhat vulnerable to this attack, as he keeps a relatively heavy lead leg and doesn't consistently check kicks.

Style Matchup Dynamics

This matchup presents a fascinating clash between Gastelum's experience and technical boxing against Pyfer's raw power and pressure. Pyfer's forward pressure style could play directly into Gastelum's counter-striking hands, particularly his left straight-right hook combination that has troubled many opponents.

Gastelum's southpaw stance creates a specific challenge for Pyfer, who has shown vulnerability to straight punches down the middle. Gastelum's straight left from southpaw could find a home against Pyfer's high guard defense that often leaves openings for straight shots.

Pyfer's tendency to load up on his right hand makes him somewhat predictable against an experienced fighter like Gastelum. In his fight against Israel Adesanya, Gastelum demonstrated excellent timing against power punchers, using his speed to land first or counter effectively.

However, Gastelum's tendency to reset with his chin high creates dangerous opportunities for Pyfer's power right hand. If Gastelum falls into his habit of blitzing forward with his chin exposed, Pyfer has the power to capitalize with fight-ending shots, similar to how he finished Barriault.

Gastelum's calf kicks from southpaw could be particularly effective against Pyfer's heavy lead leg. Against Curtis, Gastelum consistently landed this kick while circling to create angles - a strategy that could work well against Pyfer's forward pressure.

Fight Phase Analysis

In the early rounds, Pyfer's pressure and power give him a significant advantage. His ability to cut off the cage and land power shots could trouble Gastelum, especially if Gastelum shows the defensive lapses he's displayed in recent fights. Pyfer's first-round finishing rate suggests he's most dangerous early, as seen in his quick dispatching of Barriault and Amedovski.

As the fight progresses to the middle rounds, Gastelum's experience and cardio typically become factors. Against Curtis and Rodriguez, Gastelum maintained a consistent pace throughout the fight, while Pyfer showed cardio issues against Hermansson. If Gastelum can weather the early storm, his technical boxing and pace could begin to take over.

In the later rounds, Gastelum's wrestling background could become more prominent. Against Brady, even in defeat, Gastelum showed good defensive wrestling fundamentals. If Pyfer begins to tire, Gastelum could mix in takedowns to control the pace and accumulate points, similar to his approach against Heinisch.

Analysis and Key Points

  • Gastelum's experience edge is massive - he's faced multiple world champions while Pyfer is still developing against mid-tier competition
  • Pyfer's power gives him a clear path to victory if he can catch Gastelum during one of his defensive lapses
  • Gastelum's southpaw stance creates specific challenges for Pyfer, who struggled with straight punches against Hermansson
  • Cardio could be a deciding factor - Gastelum typically maintains his pace while Pyfer has shown fatigue in longer fights
  • Gastelum's calf kicks from southpaw could be effective against Pyfer's heavy lead leg and forward pressure

Understanding the Prediction

WolfTicketsAI's prediction is heavily influenced by several key factors:

  • Odds decreased the prediction score by 20.0, indicating the betting market strongly favors Pyfer
  • Recent win percentage increased the score by 2.0, reflecting Pyfer's stronger recent record
  • Significant striking impact differential and TrueSkill both increased the score by 1.0, suggesting Pyfer has advantages in striking power and overall skill level
  • Reach decreased the score by 1.0, acknowledging Gastelum's disadvantage in this area

Past Model Performance

WolfTicketsAI has a mixed record predicting both fighters. The model correctly predicted Gastelum's win over Daniel Rodriguez but incorrectly predicted Chris Curtis would defeat Gastelum. For Pyfer, the model has been largely accurate, correctly predicting his wins over Marc-Andre Barriault, Abdul Razak Alhassan, and Gerald Meerschaert, but incorrectly predicting he would defeat Jack Hermansson.

This mixed record suggests some uncertainty in this matchup, particularly given Gastelum's inconsistency and Pyfer's limited UFC experience against top competition.

Conclusion

While Gastelum brings vastly more experience against elite competition, Pyfer's power, youth, and recent momentum give him the edge in this matchup. Gastelum's technical vulnerabilities—particularly his tendency to reset with his chin high and overcommit to blitzing entries—create dangerous openings for Pyfer's power punching. Though Gastelum's southpaw stance and technical boxing will present challenges, Pyfer's pressure and finishing ability should ultimately prevail as WolfTicketsAI predicts.

Stat Breakdown

Stat Kelvin Gastelum Joe Pyfer
Main Stats
Age 33 28
Height 69" 74"
Reach 71" 75"
Win Percentage 68.97% 81.25%
Wins 20 14
Losses 10 3
Wins at Weight Class 7 4
Losses at Weight Class 6 1
Striking Stats
Striking Accuracy 46.66% 39.65%
Significant Striking Accuracy 42.41% 39.39%
Strikes Landed Per Minute 4.622 3.861
Significant Strikes Landed Per Minute 3.737 3.787
Knockdowns per Fight 0.431 0.738
Striking Impact Differential 0.83% -12.60%
Significant Striking Impact Differential 3.52% 0.20%
Striking Output Differential 5.17% -3.00%
Significant Striking Output Differential 8.00% 14.40%
Striking Defense to Offense Ratio 107.39% 121.66%
Significant Striking Defense to Offense Ratio 127.01% 107.79%
Striking Defense Percentage 57.71% 52.04%
Takedown and Submission Stats
Submissions per Fight 0.096 0.738
Takedowns per Fight 1.102 1.107
Takedowns Attempted per Fight 3.162 3.689
Takedown Defense 69.39% 100.00%
Takedown Accuracy 34.85% 30.00%
Head Stats
Head Strikes Landed per Minute 2.482 2.287
Head Strikes Attempted per Minute 7.203 7.525
Head Strikes Absorbed per Minute 2.214 2.041
Body Stats
Body Strikes Landed per Minute 0.645 1.082
Body Strikes Attempted per Minute 0.894 1.426
Body Strikes Absorbed per Minute 0.754 0.516
Leg Stats
Leg Strikes Landed per Minute 0.610 0.418
Leg kicks Attempted per Minute 0.716 0.664
Leg kicks Absorbed per Minute 0.511 1.205
Clinch Stats
Clinch Strikes Landed per Minute 0.339 0.049
Clinch Strikes Attempted per Minute 0.537 0.049
Clinch Strikes Absorbed per Minute 0.303 0.123
Kelvin Gastelum History:
Date Weight Red Corner Blue Corner Winner
June 22, 2024 Middleweight Kelvin Gastelum Daniel Rodriguez Kelvin Gastelum
Dec. 2, 2023 Welterweight Sean Brady Kelvin Gastelum Sean Brady
April 8, 2023 Middleweight Chris Curtis Kelvin Gastelum Kelvin Gastelum
Aug. 21, 2021 Middleweight Jared Cannonier Kelvin Gastelum Jared Cannonier
April 17, 2021 Middleweight Robert Whittaker Kelvin Gastelum Robert Whittaker
Feb. 13, 2021 Middleweight Kelvin Gastelum Ian Heinisch Kelvin Gastelum
July 18, 2020 Middleweight Jack Hermansson Kelvin Gastelum Jack Hermansson
Nov. 2, 2019 Middleweight Kelvin Gastelum Darren Till Darren Till
April 13, 2019 UFC Interim Middleweight Title Kelvin Gastelum Israel Adesanya Israel Adesanya
May 12, 2018 Middleweight Jacare Souza Kelvin Gastelum Kelvin Gastelum
Nov. 25, 2017 Middleweight Michael Bisping Kelvin Gastelum Kelvin Gastelum
July 22, 2017 Middleweight Chris Weidman Kelvin Gastelum Chris Weidman
March 11, 2017 Middleweight Vitor Belfort Kelvin Gastelum None
Dec. 10, 2016 Middleweight Tim Kennedy Kelvin Gastelum Kelvin Gastelum
July 9, 2016 Welterweight Johny Hendricks Kelvin Gastelum Kelvin Gastelum
Nov. 21, 2015 Welterweight Neil Magny Kelvin Gastelum Neil Magny
June 13, 2015 Middleweight Kelvin Gastelum Nate Marquardt Kelvin Gastelum
Jan. 31, 2015 Welterweight Tyron Woodley Kelvin Gastelum Tyron Woodley
Nov. 15, 2014 Welterweight Jake Ellenberger Kelvin Gastelum Kelvin Gastelum
June 28, 2014 Welterweight Kelvin Gastelum Nicholas Musoke Kelvin Gastelum
March 15, 2014 Welterweight Kelvin Gastelum Rick Story Kelvin Gastelum
Aug. 28, 2013 Welterweight Kelvin Gastelum Brian Melancon Kelvin Gastelum
April 13, 2013 Ultimate Fighter 17 Middleweight Tournament Title Uriah Hall Kelvin Gastelum Kelvin Gastelum
Joe Pyfer History:
Date Weight Red Corner Blue Corner Winner
June 29, 2024 Middleweight Joe Pyfer Marc-Andre Barriault Joe Pyfer
Feb. 10, 2024 Middleweight Jack Hermansson Joe Pyfer Jack Hermansson
Oct. 7, 2023 Middleweight Joe Pyfer Abdul Razak Alhassan Joe Pyfer
April 8, 2023 Middleweight Gerald Meerschaert Joe Pyfer Joe Pyfer
Sept. 17, 2022 Middleweight Joe Pyfer Alen Amedovski Joe Pyfer